• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Noob Daytona 116500 v3 Black dial review and comparison with gen - Pic heavy

Tobel

Respected Member
6/7/17
5,456
3,673
113
There's been quite some content posted on the 116500LN white dial, but not so much about the black dial, so I thought that a little review could be beneficial.

The Daytona 116500 had been on my radar for quite a while. But being OCD and specifically about SELs it was a no go for me with the Noob V1/V2, and since I wanted the functioning chrono, ARF was not an option either (and their SELs' quality had gone down anyway...).

So when Noob released their V3 with improved SELs, I could not resist anymore. Everyday that I was looking at the reflections on my gen 116610's ceramic insert, I thought that I needed another ceramic bezeled Rolex. As a friend of mine is looking to buy the gen white dialed, I went for the black, which has the added benefit to attract a little (but just a little) less attention.

I ordered through Li at Jtime, along with the CF bezel that he mounted for me. Amazing guy and transaction, real fast and a pleasure to deal with. I highly recommend him.

3 days after being shipped the postman rang the doorbell and here it was. Shipping was twice faster than expected so it was a nice surprise and I got to enjoy the watch over the weekend. So here it is! Please note that the below are only my own modest observations and opinions.

In short, this watch is not perfect but it is definitely an amazing rep. As I mentioned in another thread, I brought it to a little watchsmith to get the bracelet resized and while the guy also services gen Rolex's - and happened to have a gen 116520 in his shop -, he was not sure whether it was a gen or a rep, and once I told him that it was a rep he kept telling me how good it is, and showing it to his wife who was there in the shop :)

Quick reminder, the below pictures are with the CF bezel.

Pros
-Overall the finish is great, looks premium and very gen like
-Very nice dial (except the shiny subdials as per below)
-Thin subdials as per gen
-Movement so far works very well, super silent and winding is very smooth, almost as gen
-Lume has perfect color and is quite strong, even though it does not last as long as gen (compared to gen 116610)


Cons
Fixable
-the strap feels flimsy and the clasp is not as tight as an ARF clasp (at least the one from the ARF sub that I have). This should be fixable with an oil bath and I think a new spring bar in the clasp
-Crystal sits a little too high and has a white border - height should be fixable by shaving the crystal gasket. Not quite clear yet if I need to change the crystal or just the gasket to get rid of the white effect but it's doable

Non fixable
-Shiny subdials noticeable only in some lighting conditions, see below
-Super tiny SEL gaps but thet are not visible with the naked eye. So not really a con
-Rehaut engraving is not well aligned with minute markers, which was disappointing to me as I always thought that Noob was great at that. Now the rehaut on the Daytona is smaller than on the Sub, so it's less visible

Since pictures are worth a thousand words, let's get to it. You will also see some pictures of a gen that I had the chance to see at an AD (but it was not for sale, that was very frustrating)

KkLKF.md.jpg

KkhBp.md.jpg

KkK5b.md.jpg

Kk2R5.md.jpg

Kke9t.md.jpg

Kk5s2.md.jpg

KkWDE.md.jpg

Kkaqn.md.jpg

KkiX3.md.jpg

Kkmbs.md.jpg

KkqUY.md.jpg

KkIQD.md.jpg




Gen:
KkORk.md.jpg

Kkyho.md.jpg




Here you can see the crystal height and the white border,
KkrXQ.md.jpg




compared to gen:
KkQUR.md.jpg

KktxL.md.jpg



In the pic below, I tried to capture how shiny the subdials are. Unfortunately in real life it's more visible than on the pic, but again it's only under certain lighting conditions. Next to it is the gen, whose subdials remain mat and satiny even under harsh artificial lights
KklQ8.md.jpg

KkpfK.md.jpg



Here is the clasp. As you can see the main part can move maybe half a millimeter sideways, giving that impression of flimsiness. I suspect that the springbar with the red arrow is at fault, which could be fixed - I suspect - with a higher diameter springbar. Pic 1 is well aligned Clasp, and pic 2 is when you move it sideways
KkXuj.md.jpg

KkPhv.md.jpg

KkTn1.md.jpg




Here is a picture of the lume, and a side by side with my gen 16610
KkwII.md.jpg

KkkZ4.md.jpg





There you go, I hope that this is useful. I can only recommend this watch if you're a Daytona fan. It is great out of the box and a couple of mods will make it even better.
 
Last edited:

Tobel

Respected Member
6/7/17
5,456
3,673
113
Amazing! But sadly broken pics for tapatalk users!


Inviato dal mio iPhone utilizzando Tapatalk

Sorry mate, I don't use tapatalk and I don't know why pics are not working with it :/
 

OverTheTop

Known Member
12/11/14
119
74
28
Very very good! Now I have the white one...but I also love the black one and probably I will buy it in the next months!

I have to tell you a news that I have knew only this morning checking an Italian watches forum...
The 116500ln (both in black and in white) has at least a “mark 1” and a “mark 2” dial...
Specifically for the black one the difference stay in how the subdials shine!

Here is the links...

https://orologi.forumfree.it/m/?t=76850177

https://orologi.forumfree.it/m/?t=76855049
 
  • Like
Reactions: vcappp

Yellobird

I'm Pretty Popular
3/8/15
1,281
1,183
113
Same story with 116520, the earlier dials had beautiful champagne matte subdials while the lastest ones had terible shiny silver subdials too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: vcappp

Tobel

Respected Member
6/7/17
5,456
3,673
113
Very very good! Now I have the white one...but I also love the black one and probably I will buy it in the next months!

I have to tell you a news that I have knew only this morning checking an Italian watches forum...
The 116500ln (both in black and in white) has at least a “mark 1” and a “mark 2” dial...
Specifically for the black one the difference stay in how the subdials shine!

Here is the links...

https://orologi.forumfree.it/m/?t=76850177

https://orologi.forumfree.it/m/?t=76855049

Hey man thanks for sharing this information. I translated the page into English as I don't speak italian, and while it seems obvious from the pictures that the guy is right, it's also strange that no one else on that forum seems to believe him...

Let's see, but that would be great news!
 

M Scott

Renowned Member
22/9/18
857
1,163
93
Pros
-Overall the finish is great, looks premium and very gen like
-Very nice dial (except the shiny subdials as per below)
-Thin subdials as per gen


KkIQD.md.jpg

So far I have seen three Black Dial V3 pictures that appear to have Sub-dials that are slightly thinner than "V2.2" dial Sub-dials.

These new Black Dial V3 Sub-dials appear to be the same thickness as a Gen, but these pictures are too small in resolution to be really sure.
Even if the thickness has been fixed, it is still discouraging to see that the Sub-dials are still too shiny.
 

Tobel

Respected Member
6/7/17
5,456
3,673
113
So far I have seen three Black Dial V3 pictures that appear to have Sub-dials that are slightly thinner than "V2.2" dial Sub-dials.

These new Black Dial V3 Sub-dials appear to be the same thickness as a Gen, but these pictures are too small in resolution to be really sure.
Even if the thickness has been fixed, it is still discouraging to see that the Sub-dials are still too shiny.

Yes I had done a side by side comparison in another thread and the subdials are exactly the same thickness as gen.

I'm with you on the shininess, though OverTheTop 's post above may mean that it's not so much of an issue. It's making me curious
 
  • Like
Reactions: vcappp

M Scott

Renowned Member
22/9/18
857
1,163
93
Very very good! Now I have the white one...but I also love the black one and probably I will buy it in the next months!

I have to tell you a news that I have knew only this morning checking an Italian watches forum...
The 116500ln (both in black and in white) has at least a “mark 1” and a “mark 2” dial...
Specifically for the black one the difference stay in how the subdials shine!

Here is the links...

https://orologi.forumfree.it/m/?t=76850177

https://orologi.forumfree.it/m/?t=76855049

Even if one of these pictured Gens has shiner Sub-dials than the other, neither one appears nearly as shiny as the Noobs Sub-dials do.
.
_DSC5991_2.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: vcappp

M Scott

Renowned Member
22/9/18
857
1,163
93
Yes I had done a side by side comparison in another thread and the subdials are exactly the same thickness as gen.

It would be more helpful if you could post larger, higher resolution pictures.
 

OverTheTop

Known Member
12/11/14
119
74
28
Hey man thanks for sharing this information. I translated the page into English as I don't speak italian, and while it seems obvious from the pictures that the guy is right, it's also strange that no one else on that forum seems to believe him...

Let's see, but that would be great news!

My pleasure! I agree : this would be a great news and I trust in this guy. Why? Because “mark” apart I saw too much rolex different and with some “flaws”. In that forum I saw also a 116500 that has a misaligned rehaut! So is not a surprise.

Yeah, only few people believe him, just because about this “mark 1,2, etc.” there is too much speculation and - rightly - people are bored about that. This Daytona is already hard to get, plus every little change would make some costumer more lucky than other... seems a joke.

Hope to have explain correctly my thoughts
 
  • Like
Reactions: vcappp and Tobel

OverTheTop

Known Member
12/11/14
119
74
28
Even if one of these pictured Gens has shiner Sub-dials than the other, neither one appears nearly as shiny as the Noobs Sub-dials do.
.
_DSC5991_2.jpg

I’ve never seen in real life the V3 Black so I can’t imagine how it shine..but the fact that in those two gen one is matte and one is shiny “giustificate” those kind of subdials in the v3 :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: vcappp

molivio

I'm Pretty Popular
Certified
19/10/15
1,148
194
63
One of the screws holding the links together fell out on mine, where can I buy a replacement