I have both and love both. They are different in their own way. Get both.
You're a bad influence
Above motion seconded!Get both, and get OEM straps for each.
I've also searched for some comparison pics side by side but didn't find any; if anyone has some of those that would be great thanks!
Simona is a great strap and very comfortable. I have found the oem slightly softer, but that could just be that I am comparing a JV to a Simona gator.I used to be a big fan of OEM Panerai straps. Then I was introduced to Simona DiStefano. The Bentley of watch straps.