Check that your rubber strap is trimmed neatly down and not preventing a secure closure. But since you wore it for that long kind doubtful. Check when the rubber is connected, make sure the holes for the springbars are not torn open.
The spring operated release may be failing take a look at those on each side look for excessive play maybe.
Lastly, the actual inward or outward "tabs" of the butterfly might just simply need bent a little. They are made from thinner steel so you can bend them easily. Examine how the clasp operates, spot where the friction keeps it all closed up together and then bend the problem area in very VERY small amounts, checking the closure each time until its where you want it.