Glad to hear it worked for you all!
All the reps I've seen which claim to have ceramic bezels have got them and they're pretty well made. Ceramics are hard as f*ck, so unless you've whacked them on a diamond, they won't have scratched. The pencil eraser embeds the particles left from the other substance into the rubber and encapsulates them for easy removal.
The same is true for sapphire crystals; my wife put on a Tag rep I got for her straight from the box and within seconds, scraped the crystal on a concrete lamppost (no idea how) and it looked terrible, just like when you fell off your bike as a kid and ground your casio along the pavement! As it was a sapphire crystal the marks were actually just ground concrete on the crystal, and 2 seconds with some alcohol brought the crystal back to 100%.