BB Blue of BB Black?

[fettuccine]

Hi Everyone - brand new to RWI, but my friend has recently shown me his replicas that came from Puretime, and I must say they are awesome!

I am looking to purchase a Black Bay Shield ZF, but wanted some feedback on both the black and blue bezels.

Blue: https://puretime.io/heritage-black-bay-blue-zf-1-1-best-edition-on-bracelet-a2824-v5.html
Black: https://puretime.io/heritage-2016-b...-best-edition-on-ss-bracelet-a2824-black.html

I am specifically looking for feedback on any color defects on the dial/bezel/hands, feel of the rotating bezel, quality of movement, bracelet/clasp quality (any rattling, clicks, etc), etc.

So I guess the real question is, which is the overall better watch?!

Thanks!

 

[Pyknic]

neither, red shield edition.

 

[pengo]

superrep-list is wrong on BB(or incomplete ).
the blue has a better 3D-print on dial. red n black gold-print is flat.
but doesnt really matter, all 3 are very nice.

this is mine:

 

[GoatTaFuk]

Wow nice! Where did you get this from? Looking for my first rep, thank you!


Sent from my iPhone using RWI

 

[Yknjs]

superrep-list is wrong on BB(or incomplete ).
the blue has a better 3D-print on dial. red n black gold-print is flat.
but doesnt really matter, all 3 are very nice.

this is mine:

Totally agree!
I have a gen black bay red shield,the rep it’s damn good!
Same feeling for S&G and steel...
The blue of your bezel it’s correct?
Have you compared with a gen in real?
Thanks

 

[pengo]

Wow nice! Where did you get this from? Looking for my first rep, thank you!


Sent from my iPhone using RWI

thx mate.

chazingtime

 

[pengo]

Totally agree!
I have a gen black bay red shield,the rep it’s damn good!
Same feeling for S&G and steel...
The blue of your bezel it’s correct?
Have you compared with a gen in real?
Thanks

didnt had a gen in hand, just saw it in a shopwindow and loved it and decided to buy the rep.
here on repforums it was complained about the blue color, and many said on this version the blue is corrected to genlike color?!
im not really sure, but i guess the gen blue is a little darker.
but again i didnt very much compare in real, but when i compared internet-pics, i still think gen blue is darker. ???

but as u can see on the last pic: dynamic is good -> blue where the sun reflects, and almost black on the upper side.

very minor flaws are:
- xtalside is bit milky in some angles(that bothers me the most).
(there is a mod for that, but dont wana do it). on my pics it isnt visible cause i only post pics without it.
will upload a pic with that milky thing in a moment.
- crown is not as crisp as gen.
- hands are not as fine as on gen, but still great.
- and i read the pearl is fully genlike, but that doesnt bother me(there is a mod for that too).

and i guess the bezelclick isnt genlike, but i never had a gen in hand.

im very satisfied with the rep!!! its great.

 

[pengo]

milky side of the xtal:

 

[Yknjs]

Thanks for sharing your opinion mate!