• The finalists in the Mod OTY have been chosen, please go vote in the finals: MOD OTY Link
  • It's our birthday and YOU get the gifts! Eight giveaways including six watches that you can enter for free! RWI Birthday Free Gifts Link

  • Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

AP 15202 vs 15500 Comparison Photos

SOLEX

I'm Pretty Popular
Supporter
Certified
30/3/09
2,891
803
113
Hey RWI AP fans!

In addition to my comparison of 15202 vs 15450, https://forum.replica-watch.info/th...on-pics-which-to-keep.10981296/#post-11791536 I would now like to compare the 15202 vs 15500 for those that are on the fence with either model. The 15202 is the super classy and elegant legend, while the 15500 is the more modern AP.

I just want to start this comparison by saying these are ABSOLUTELY two different watches for different audiences that can actually coexist in a collection. The 15202 is classy, elegant and can be worn with a suit but is not the sportiest of watches while the 15500 certainly is a sporty watch that can be dressed up or down. Admittedly the 15202 has been my daily for a few weeks now, and I have worn it to the beach, and to meetings and it passed with flying colors. The 15500 is obviously a bigger watch, but as you will see below it does not wear so much bigger than a 15202.

I have a pretty small, but flat wrist at about 6.3", and I can honestly say the 15500 fits decently (I see it differently in the flesh despite my horrible photography skills). The 15500 is not hanging over my wrist or seems out of place HOWEVER the dial on the watch is simply massive and makes the watch look so much bigger than the 15202. As for the case itself, I could be wrong but the lug to lug (top to bottom) is about 1mm LESS on the 15500 as the lugs kind of curve at a steep slope while the 15202 is a bit more spread out. Please also note that the bracelet is wider on the 15500 at the clasp, I thought it tapered more but it did not and that is kind of surprising however overall does not really bother me.

Putting both next to each other the 15202 just gets dwarfed, but I may have to wear the 15500 around for a couple of days to see if I can get used to the massive, empty looking dial. On one hand I love the sportiness and how substantial the 15500 feels, as the 15202 is a bit more delicate and obviously with its super thin profile a bit too elegant for daily use. It would be hard to choose one over the other, but I hope this review helps anybody that is deciding between the two, or if they are looking to add either of these watches to their collection. They can easily coexist if you have a larger collection as they are two different watches that are part of the Royal Oak family.
 
Last edited:

samsoniteman

Maker of Poor Financial Decisions
Supporter
Certified
2/6/23
621
815
93
US
Looking great man! I personally prefer the 15500 on your wrist. The mirror shot really is a more accurate depiction on the wrist. Can't wait for mine to come in *AHEM @legend AHEM* :LOL:

Are you gonna keep both?
 

SOLEX

I'm Pretty Popular
Supporter
Certified
30/3/09
2,891
803
113
Funny how "low" you are wearing the watches or maybe I´m just a high roller.
I don´t like it, when the crown pinches the back of my hand.
This is a 16202.


The 15202 is a tad loose on me, so it does go up and down the wrist throughout the day, but I tend to like to wear it usually over the bone that bumps out a bit. Thankfully the crown is not a bother
 

Nono92

I'm Pretty Popular
24/11/21
2,017
814
113
No hesitation for me, it's the 15202 because lighter and thinner. If there was a second hand, it would be perfect...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dr Fun Socks

Cubatobaco

Horological Specimen
Supporter
Certified
24/6/24
724
895
93
VA
My recently acquired 15500 is a beauty, but wish that the bracelet was about 1-2mm bigger around. It certainly first more snug than I'm used to. I have a 7 inch wrist and am surprised that I didn't have to take out a link. Of course, it's a DLC and there are no extra links just laying around...lol. As I have been trying to get used to wearing it, I have started to wear it a bit higher on my wrist as the crown pushes into the back of my hand. Either way, love the 15500!
 

pam63C

WTB ZF Polaris
Certified
12/2/23
599
506
93
Asia
This is reason why I am looking for 15300 for months now
I have spend some time looking at this 15300 option too.

The best replicated one was from BP. You have to spend quite some effort and money to thin the case and to fit the 3120 movement but that's do-able. Also the 15300 gen dial is very expensive.

What killed it for me was that the bezel and hex nuts on the BP were far from being gen-like. The case construct was not accurate. Although I can live with a less than perfect case, the bezel and hex nuts stared right into your eyes that I can't ignore.
 

love_in_jumbo

Active Member
22/7/23
226
252
63
South Korea
I have spend some time looking at this 15300 option too.

The best replicated one was from BP. You have to spend quite some effort and money to thin the case and to fit the 3120 movement but that's do-able. Also the 15300 gen dial is very expensive.

What killed it for me was that the bezel and hex nuts on the BP were far from being gen-like. The case construct was not accurate. Although I can live with a less than perfect case, the bezel and hex nuts stared right into your eyes that I can't ignore.
This is one of the most informative reply I got regarding this. Thank you so much.

I tried to get BP as base but I could mot even get the BP. (Still hoping)

Thought the samething about using 3129 clone mive from 15450. But thinning the case… sigh.

Lastly did not know about bezel and the hex nut gotta go though pictures to check out. Thank you