• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

2018 Omega Seamaster Sedna Gold questions on how to spot a replica and what the genuine offers.

chubbychaser911

Active Member
31/10/19
405
112
43
I am definitely into replicas and enjoy seeing what the Chinese makers are able to produce. However, I do also own genuine watches and like what the genuine have to offer.

Right now I am considering getting a Sedna Rose Gold 2018+ Omega Seamaster on black rubber strap. I tried one on at the AD and I love it. In fact, I would prefer it to a submariner.

All that said, I was considering getting both the genuine and the replica on this watch. Since second hand market prices are so compelling I will probably buy on Chrono24. I would like to know how I can quickly authenticate the watch myself. The two biggest issues are the golden bits and the movement. The last issue is making sure that no parts have been replaced with replica parts.

For the movement I assume that the VSF cloned movement beats at 28,800 VPH and the Original is at 25,200 VPH. So a moment on a timegrapher would point that out no questions asked correct? Or will I have to look closely at the movement to determine authenticity as the beat rate has been replicated. I know there is info on teh TD sites but that info isn't always completely accurate so I prefer to hear from knowledgeable people on this site if the knowledge exists.

For the golden bits has anyone ever performed a nitric acid test on the bezel's underside? Or how do you go about testing the gold? Weighing the watch? If so, what is the weight of the genuine?

Finally, there's the question of actual value. I know that Swiss watches are not worth the money they charge except for the fact that people are willing to pay the price for exclusivity. Would it be safe to assume that what I'm paying for with the Omega is that it's real gold, and that the movement is more reliable and accurate as well as serviceable in the future.

Summary:
1. I need to know if I can tell a replica from genuine as an individual enthusiast who will be purchasing their first Omega. Determining if the gold bits are actually gold is important to me. And having a great movement is important so I want to be able to quickly discern authentic Omega 8800. I will also get the replica to wear when I don't want to risk the genuine but still want to wear something nice on my wrist. So I have no judgement about replicas obviously (I have 8 replicas at the moment).
2. If you have thoughts on if the genuine offers some tangible worthwhile benefits, I'd love to hear them. No we all have our own values and opinions with watches but I'm genuinely interested in your thoughts as a conversation topic.
 

jcagara08

I'm Pretty Popular
9/1/11
1,158
105
63
Gold replating is always an option and a movement replacement is also possible when it craps out but that's optimistic me though

Sent from my Mi 9T Pro using Tapatalk
 

micksmith1987

Renowned Member
1/9/18
628
239
43
Summary:
1. I need to know if I can tell a replica from genuine as an individual enthusiast who will be purchasing their first Omega. Determining if the gold bits are actually gold is important to me. And having a great movement is important so I want to be able to quickly discern authentic Omega 8800. I will also get the replica to wear when I don't want to risk the genuine but still want to wear something nice on my wrist. So I have no judgement about replicas obviously (I have 8 replicas at the moment).
2. If you have thoughts on if the genuine offers some tangible worthwhile benefits, I'd love to hear them. No we all have our own values and opinions with watches but I'm genuinely interested in your thoughts as a conversation topic.

1. Please read this to see how to tell the gen from rep https://forum.replica-watch.info/for...gen-comparison

Generally speaking:
1. There is a clear caseback so you can see the movement, a quick look at the balance bridge/lever and you know for sure (even with pics/videos)
2. If you can touch the watch, then just unscrew the movement and you feel the difference. It is huge - the gen is firm; the rep is flimsy
3. The other differences are impossible to tell by just looking at the watch - you need a gen to compare to. Nobody will call you out with the rep on your wrist. Even if you hand them the watch, they would not be able to tell gen/rep (except for the movement issue).

2. When it comes to whether the gen is worth it... I'd say yes, it is. 300m are absolutely amazing watches. I have several gens: the sedna gold, moonwatch, 39mm speedmaster, and a nodate sub... I must say, the 300m is my favorite in terms of how it wears. The rubber strap is awesome. I might prefer the look of the sub, and the history behind the moonwatch, but 300m is super comfy.

PS: I assume you mean the stainless steel case and rose gold bezel, right? Cause if I am not mistaken there are no full rose gold 300m on black strap (the only one is blue dial/blue strap)
 
Last edited:

chubbychaser911

Active Member
31/10/19
405
112
43
Thanks for the thoughtful response. Yes I want the one with rose gold bezel and stainless case. When it has rose gold I find it to be aesthetically superior to the submariner In Stainless. When it’s just steel I find the submariner to be superior. Thanks for the tips on identifying the movement as gen. Now I just need to make sure that I don’t buy a second hand watch that has had a VSF bezel swapped on.
 

rek00001

Active Member
24/4/13
219
80
28
Your description of the 300m makes me want to consider buying the gen.