• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Help choosing a Cartier Ballon Bleu rep!...

Cee

Renowned Member
1/6/11
691
5
0
Hello there fellow watch geeks!

I'm currently in the market for a accurate Cartier Ballon Bleu rep (42mm men's version) however I am having trouble picking out the 'best' watch for me, so some input from you guys would be greatly appreciated!

It seems that there are several different examples of this watch available and I have somewhat narrowed my search down to 4 which are all linked below:

1) Ballon Bleu SS on Bracelet ETA2892 Ultimate Edition - $628
2) Ballon Bleu SS on Bracelet ETA2892 Ultimate Edition V2 - $528
3) Ballon Bleu SS on Bracelet ETA2892 - $498
4) CARTIER BALLON DE CARTIER SS 42MM SWISS ETA 2824 - $308

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

1) Firstly the most expensive option from PureTime - $628

cartier2010051901022enl.jpg

cartier2010051901062enl.jpg


To my untrained eye this looks like a very good and accurate replica. Correct date font and the movement is nicely engraved.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

2) Second option, which seems identical to the first one to me, can anyone see the differences? It is exactly $100 less at $528, surely this must be for a reason?

ctr201010260102enl.jpg

ctr201010260109enl.jpg


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

3) Next is the $498 rep also from PureTime. Am I right in thinking that the watch is almost exactly the same apart from the detailed movement?

ctrbbsssseta289202enl.jpg

ctrbbsssseta289209enl.jpg


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

4) Lastly is the cheapest version on my list from Lay at ReplicaMake (who is no longer a TD here). At $308 it is less than half the price of option 1 and the only differences I can see is the wrong date font and plain movement. Am I missing something? Surely it is not worth the extra $300+ just for these minor details?

ctr04001cartierballonde.jpg

ctr04001cartierballonde.jpg


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Usually I go on the basis that 'you get what you pay for' although I'm not sure that it can be applied in this situation as to me the watches seem very similar.

Anyone out there who could assist me in this? Maybe you own the same watch and could share details and information about it? Not only would this be useful for me in my decision making, but it will no doubt help others who are (or will be) in the same situation.

Thanks all! :)
 

R2D4

Admin
Advisor
15/4/07
14,909
54
48
Date font would drive me nuts. :)

Not an expert but, I would inquire to see what is in stock
 

5up3rman

Renowned Member
4/12/10
964
2
0
the thing which bugs me is that the gen has a domed crystal.
I dont think any rep has this.

i could be worn though
 

Cee

Renowned Member
1/6/11
691
5
0
the thing which bugs me is that the gen has a domed crystal.
I dont think any rep has this.

i could be worn though

I'm 99% sure the rep also has a domed crystal, although I am not sure what it is like compared to the gen version.
 

BEAU

Banned member, the goat does not approve
Banned
19/7/10
361
0
0
I want one too..any other dealers carry this watch??
 

Cee

Renowned Member
1/6/11
691
5
0
Well it seems that the majority of our trusted dealers have this in stock and available, the problem is picking the 'best' one.
 

Celt

Renowned Member
12/4/10
757
5
18
the thing which bugs me is that the gen has a domed crystal.
I dont think any rep has this.

i could be worn though

I think that you are wrong, mine (36mm) is domed... here next to an explorer:

IMG_3401.jpg

IMG_3397.jpg


And My brother in law has a gen 36mm rose gold ballon bleun, guess what, the crystal looked just like mine ;)
 

nycreplica

Renowned Member
14/1/11
647
2
18
Let us know how it shakes out, I'm also about to purchase the 42mm version
 

Cee

Renowned Member
1/6/11
691
5
0
I think that you are wrong, mine (36mm) is domed... here next to an explorer:

IMG_3401.jpg

IMG_3397.jpg


And My brother in law has a gen 36mm rose gold ballon bleun, guess what, the crystal looked just like mine ;)

Thanks for clearing this up! The dealers photo's never seem to do the watch any justice.
 

Klokkeren

Known Member
24/1/11
112
8
18
I have a friend that bought the nr. 1 from Puretime, I can ask him if I can take som pics of it. and post it for you. I think that version has an ETA 2893-2 with an real Cartier engraved rotor. The rest I think they all are som sort of chinese movements in them.

But IMHO it is a realy impressive and beautyfull watch IRL.
 

RolexPresident

Banned member, the goat does not approve
Banned
6/7/09
217
0
0
I bought it when it first came out from Stan and mine has the domed crystal in 21J 42MM size. nice watch!