• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Worth buying a cf hulk dial for the VSF hulk?

Yogibear

I'm Pretty Popular
21/8/19
1,409
614
113
I thought ZF and VSF were both great? I am planning on buying the ZF due to having the best Dial. ZF and VSF did tie in the Hulk Showdown Review.

ZF has the best hulk dial in reps. ZF like another user said is dark like Gen. VSF was much lighter in green. The ZZF even had a better colour than VSF.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BLY

StreetFighter

Insert Coin
4/9/20
2,880
3,430
113
ZF has the best hulk dial in reps. ZF like another user said is dark like Gen. VSF was much lighter in green. The ZZF even had a better colour than VSF.

I disagree. See below..

Not sure if I have already posted my photo here, too.
Shows the different laser, cartwheel, disco dial effects.
VSF, ZZF v3, Noob v10s, Gen.
Gen is the 2nd watch with significant lighter effect.

VSF/Gen/Noob/ZZF(clean)


I think the VSF is closest to gen.. here is gen and VSF again..

There is neither one of them 'much lighter in green'. They are all pretty much the same green with differing sunbursts or laser effect. of which I would pick VSF.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Harhar

Malaka

Known Member
5/9/19
112
45
28
Germany
Correct, imho.
VSF ist slightly lighter than gen. But this is completely irrelevant considering the sunburst/laser effect which is a way more obvious tell.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Stevenf

Yogibear

I'm Pretty Popular
21/8/19
1,409
614
113
I disagree. See below..



VSF/Gen/Noob/ZZF(clean)
Zf2GVo.jpg



I think the VSF is closest to gen.. here is gen and VSF again..
Zf20aJ.jpg

There is neither one of them 'much lighter in green'. They are all pretty much the same green with differing sunbursts or laser effect. of which I would pick VSF.

Look at the the 1st and 2nd pics.... It's in a lighting that majority of us are in... Workplace, mall, home etc... The VSF dial looks terrible in that lighting. It's so light and not even close to Gen.
Now look at the 3rd pic...Your telling me I have to go outside on a sunny day under a tree just to have my hulk VSF kind of match with genuine lmao. A ZF in the 1st and 2nd pics would look the best.
 
Last edited:

Roguetheory

Active Member
7/9/20
449
215
43
EU
I disagree. See below..



VSF/Gen/Noob/ZZF(clean)
Zf2GVo.jpg



I think the VSF is closest to gen.. here is gen and VSF again..
Zf20aJ.jpg

There is neither one of them 'much lighter in green'. They are all pretty much the same green with differing sunbursts or laser effect. of which I would pick VSF.

...
 
Last edited:

Shany

Active Member
24/6/19
257
73
28
There is no ZF in the comparison.
Yes Iam Sure it was post raid arrived this weekend
 

VaderTime

Active Member
9/10/17
449
167
43
Gen dial should become very dark, almost black at certain angles which resembles the Kermit. My VSF just can't become that dark and I can still see the green at the darkest angle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yogibear

StreetFighter

Insert Coin
4/9/20
2,880
3,430
113
Gen dial should become very dark, almost black at certain angles which resembles the Kermit. My VSF just can't become that dark and I can still see the green at the darkest angle.

This is at odds with my findings too.. as below.. my VSF Hulk doing a really good kermit impression..

Zferao.jpg
ZfetlJ.jpg
ZfeBFP.jpg
Zfe6Jk.jpg
ZfelAW.jpg
Zfep6S.jpg
 
Last edited:

Yogibear

I'm Pretty Popular
21/8/19
1,409
614
113
Gen dial should become very dark, almost black at certain angles which resembles the Kermit. My VSF just can't become that dark and I can still see the green at the darkest angle.

It's crazy how many people will recommend VSF as the hulk to buy yet it fails at one of the most important parts of the hulk and that is the Dial.
 

StreetFighter

Insert Coin
4/9/20
2,880
3,430
113
It's crazy how many people will recommend VSF as the hulk to buy yet it fails at one of the most important parts of the hulk and that is the Dial.

So do they all though? Look at bowtie on the genuine watch above, none of the reps can manage that no matter how close the colour is.

The genuine dial is made using a process involving gold, no rep will ever do that.. found this..

The dial is mainly brass and they apply a mixture of gold powder and aluminium powder very similar to PVD coating to dial but its not solid gold if it was it would have to be hallmarked.And at one time Rolex did advertise it as being green gold on there web site.But it was soon removed as you cannot state anything thats gold unless its real solid gold like say 9Ct,15Ct,18Ct,22Ct, etc.And if over a certain weight and the dial would be it would have to bare a assay mark.

Just read down the text in the picture below.
 

diamant

I'm Pretty Popular
Supporter
Certified
9/9/19
1,557
1,212
113
Gen dial in different lightning conditions for you guys


Thanks m8.

No rep can match that dark forest! Such a lovely dial.
also see the insert is very close but missing the emerald shine to it.

Do someone have the newest CLEAN dial or watch?
ZF almost had it but now is bad? Lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: mari115

Yogibear

I'm Pretty Popular
21/8/19
1,409
614
113
So do they all though? Look at bowtie on the genuine watch above, none of the reps can manage that no matter how close the colour is.

The genuine dial is made using a process involving gold, no rep will ever do that.. found this..

The dial is mainly brass and they apply a mixture of gold powder and aluminium powder very similar to PVD coating to dial but its not solid gold if it was it would have to be hallmarked.And at one time Rolex did advertise it as being green gold on there web site.But it was soon removed as you cannot state anything thats gold unless its real solid gold like say 9Ct,15Ct,18Ct,22Ct, etc.And if over a certain weight and the dial would be it would have to bare a assay mark.

Just read down the text in the picture below.

I understand but nothing is perfect to gen on any replica in general. We just hope for the closest thing possible and live with it or we franken it... The VSF doesn't come close to the dark green were looking for on a Hulk dial but the ZF does. I'm not saying its gen like, but out of all the hulk reps available to us, ZF has the best dial colour( I say colour because the markers on vsf is better) ... Unless it really did get worse after the raids.
 

macarone

Put Some Respect On My Name
Patron
Certified
7/3/17
5,100
2,984
113
CONUS USA
You guys can argue all you want but VSF is the BEST one. I've had them all. Enjoying and laughing at this thread while wearing my VSF. The entire watch is superb including the dial and markers AND the crystal which is the best out of all the makers hands down.

https://i.ibb.co/VB38STf/IMG-20210103-110358.jpg

IMG-20210103-110340.jpg


IMG-20210103-105830.jpg


IMG-20210103-105459.jpg

Looks great in the shade, sun light is the dials enemy. I own a vsf but won’t wear it out of the house.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk