• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Noob Daytona vs ARF Daytona

guru

Advisor
Advisor
30/9/06
11,640
1,221
113
Mate, you and I did a lot of research on those models, both did comprehensive analysis and you took it to a new level.

However, having done more 'in the field' research since, I am 100% positive there have been variations in this dial. I know a guy in the UK here who owns THREE ceramic tonas, two white dial (2018,2019) and one black. Having seen them side by side there is unquestionably a difference in the two white dials, not necessarily in the subdial thickness but perhaps the finish of the subdial outer ring giving the perception. Whether it is down to perception, production tolerance, milieu, I don't know, but these were both unequivocally gens.

I've also seen the red DAYTONA on a 2016 model with a marginally different font!

I wish I could have introduced you to be honest!!

I don‘t post much and I try to add value and I hate to push my postcount up with stupid posts....but I agree with you, the first released models of 116500 had smaller subdial. I still have pictures of the first release. The difference is so small that you do not see it with a normal eye, only if you do a comparison like M Scott did. Btw, thanks for that.
I like the first release better because the subdial look close to my 16520 Zenith model.But that is just me...


Sent from my iPad with Tapatalk
 

M Scott

Renowned Member
22/9/18
815
1,046
93
Mate, you and I did a lot of research on those models, both did comprehensive analysis and you took it to a new level.

However, having done more 'in the field' research since, I am 100% positive there have been variations in this dial. I know a guy in the UK here who owns THREE ceramic tonas, two white dial (2018,2019) and one black. Having seen them side by side there is unquestionably a difference in the two white dials, not necessarily in the subdial thickness but perhaps the finish of the subdial outer ring giving the perception. Whether it is down to perception, production tolerance, milieu, I don't know, but these were both unequivocally gens.

I've also seen the red DAYTONA on a 2016 model with a marginally different font!

I wish I could have introduced you to be honest!!

Thanks for your reply and for your kind words ssouthall6.

I certainly can not dispute the years of first hand experience and the knowledge that come from being able to make side by side comparisons in person.
Having worked in Industrial Design for over 35 years, my experience with design and tooling cost make it seem unlikely to me that a detail like the sub-dial thickness would be changed one year and then changed back another. However, changes in color or finishes are an entirely different story. Rolex is a company with a certain amount of perceived perfection, but it seems that we are learning that some details can vary in production runs, or batches. We would like to think that Gens are consistent and perfect, but we are learning that is not always the case.

Wow wow, calm down guys you both are experts that helped us a lot.
Don’t ruin that on who is more right.

Don't worry, I have tremendous respect for ssouthall6 and his years of experience.
Sometimes we see things from a different point of view, but he has pushed me to go research and learn more of the details that make this hobby interesting and fun.

I don‘t post much and I try to add value and I hate to push my postcount up with stupid posts....but

At over 11000 posts so far... I'm thinking you may have made one or two stupid posts before ;-)

I don‘t post much and I try to add value and I hate to push my postcount up with stupid posts....but I agree with you, the first released models of 116500 had smaller subdial. I still have pictures of the first release. The difference is so small that you do not see it with a normal eye, only if you do a comparison like M Scott did. Btw, thanks for that.
I like the first release better because the subdial look close to my 16520 Zenith model.But that is just me...

It makes sense that the first released 116500 models had slightly smaller or thinner sub-dials.
Rolex made all of their Silver sub-dials the same thickness, but the Black sub-dials on the 116500 Pandas are thicker for a reason...
ARF incorrectly made all of their sub-dials the same thickness, and when you look at the picture below of all of them together, the Black sub-dials appear visually slimmer. Just as some women like to wear Black to appear slimmer. It is also why the White Dial Daytonas visually "wear larger" on the wrist.

Rolex made the Black sub-dials on the 116500 Pandas are thicker so that they would visually appear closer to the thickness of the Silver sub-dials.

Right click and open image in a new tab to see these ARF pictures larger...
VbiJn3.jpg


Apparently someone at Rolex decided after the first production run in 2016 that the Black sub-dials on the 116500 Panda needed to be slightly thicker.

Personally, I prefer the slightly thinner sub-dials of the ARF and if I was going to build a White 116500 Daytona, I would use an ARF dial just as ssouthall6 and guru have done with their's.

Some may decide that this is just more needless nitpicking, but to others it is Appreciation for the Precision, the Details, and the Craftsmanship that go into the Genuine watches.
​​​​​​​It is also Appreciation and Studying just how close these Replicas continue to come to the Gens.
 

ssouthall6

Put Some Respect On My Name
10/10/13
3,539
1,562
113
Thanks for your reply and for your kind words ssouthall6.

I certainly can not dispute the years of first hand experience and the knowledge that come from being able to make side by side comparisons in person.
Having worked in Industrial Design for over 35 years, my experience with design and tooling cost make it seem unlikely to me that a detail like the sub-dial thickness would be changed one year and then changed back another. However, changes in color or finishes are an entirely different story. Rolex is a company with a certain amount of perceived perfection, but it seems that we are learning that some details can vary in production runs, or batches. We would like to think that Gens are consistent and perfect, but we are learning that is not always the case.



Don't worry, I have tremendous respect for ssouthall6 and his years of experience.
Sometimes we see things from a different point of view, but he has pushed me to go research and learn more of the details that make this hobby interesting and fun.

Exactly. This is not a case of us disagreeing. I'm glad you saw it that way. I agree with your analysis 100%. I really wonder what was causing the optical 'illusion' of a difference, and I have to agree with you, I think it is in the 'sheen' created by a differential finish or perhaps laquer around the subdial.

It's one of those moments when you wish your eyes are loupes :D


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

guru

Advisor
Advisor
30/9/06
11,640
1,221
113
At over 11000 posts so far... I'm thinking you may have made one or two stupid posts before ;-)

I remember some of those, lol (this is one)



Sent from my iPad with Tapatalk
 

Digital.

I'm Pretty Popular
Patron
Certified
25/7/15
1,086
545
113
I just bought a beautiful Panerai "Tuttonero" and I received perfect service from InTime shop. I took a taste and I would now like to proceed with a new purchase ... but I feel insecure. Can someone help me with this one? https://www.intime04.co/rollie/5816...on-rubber-strap-sa4130-free-rubber-strap.html
It is really worth the price? Thank you for your consideration...


Inviato dal mio iPad utilizzando Tapatalk

Take your time, read all 1586 posts and you will have your answe
 
  • Like
Reactions: M Scott

SWI

Known Member
1/11/17
181
80
28
Canada
I just bought a beautiful Panerai "Tuttonero" and I received perfect service from InTime shop. I took a taste and I would now like to proceed with a new purchase ... but I feel insecure. Can someone help me with this one? https://www.intime04.co/rollie/5816...on-rubber-strap-sa4130-free-rubber-strap.html
It is really worth the price? Thank you for your consideration...


Inviato dal mio iPad utilizzando Tapatalk

Just realize the gen is white gold and this is SS. This is my favourite Daytona but I’m torn also because of this fact. I’ve tried on a white gold submariner at a Rolex AD and it has such a distinct look to the metal. This Daytona has the oyster flex and so has a lot less metal which makes me think it could pass but I don’t know. Would love to see a real life gen comparison.
 

KJ2020

Time Traveler
Supporter
12/3/18
32,399
56,937
113
Just realize the gen is white gold and this is SS. This is my favourite Daytona but I’m torn also because of this fact. I’ve tried on a white gold submariner at a Rolex AD and it has such a distinct look to the metal. This Daytona has the oyster flex and so has a lot less metal which makes me think it could pass but I don’t know. Would love to see a real life gen comparison.

Unless someone has a WG right next to yours 99% of people won't be able to tell anything is different. These are so beautiful to wear, don't deny yourself because of a few shades of silver color.

VM8zoX.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: guru and SWI

geoxman

Banned member, the goat does not approve
Banned
20/2/19
40
7
0
I have been keeping up the the noob version of this watch for while.
I do know there are slight varations in the SOH blue face vs the gen. Has anyone compared the blue on the face of this vs the gen? I can't find anything
https://www.intime04.co/rollie/6066-...65mm-65mm.html

Thanks-I know it is a long shot because the watch is not that common!
 
Last edited:

Bobi01

Put Some Respect On My Name
2/2/19
3,745
3,110
113
Bro it is so gen-look...your sels are perfect too
 

dashing

Dashing Around
Supporter
20/5/18
242
96
28
Metroville
Through some bad (good) luck, I ended up with 2 ARF dials.
However, I realised that there are some minute differences between these 2 ARF dials with regards to their printing.
  1. #1 has a thinner font compared to #2, obvious on the 'COSMOGRAPH'
  2. 'R' of the 'ROLEX' in #1 is not aligned to the 'S' in 'OYSTER' on the line below. It is aligned on #2.
  3. Subdials font is thinner on #1 compared to #2
So, to all experts and noobs, which one should I choose to switch onto my NOOB?

VxyBxZ.jpg
 
Last edited: