• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

Noob Daytona vs ARF Daytona

beau7816

Banned member, the goat does not approve
Banned
20/9/16
6,933
1,684
113
UK Devon
Cavalli I think you will get a cheaper price from Puretime (i have used them for many purchases)
 

lcsrep11

Active Member
19/8/17
203
93
28
Went round hatton garden on my lunch break. Cheapest 2017 Ceramic used is $22k. No sign of one for $16k? You must be as good watch expert as you are a negotiator if you can tell the Noob on wrist. Unless you are side by side with the gen you will have trouble mate seriously. As per usual on RWI people are comparing magnified images etc. I’ve got a ceramic gmt gen mos people on here would the SEL is wrong blah blah.

The Noob 4130 is a big milestone in reps the movement is amazing. That’s why it’s selling like crazy.

They must see you coming pal. You must also be as good at doing deals as you are at reading. I initially said i've seen them go for as low as $16900 / £13k I never mentioned $16k. I also showed you three places which all have them for sale right now for the equivalent of between $18k to $18.5k both in the UK and USA.....a huge saving. You said initially you were struggling to find the watch "anywhere upwards of $24000" the definition of "upwards of" or correct me if i'm wrong is greater than / in excess of. I was only trying to show where to get one cheaper that is all. You have found one today for $22000 so guess your making progress.

Totally agree the noob clone movement is a huge leap and an amazing milestone. Ive never ever said otherwise.

That picture that you posted of the ceramic Daytona with black dials I could tell all day long. They are far too big, magnified or not on a small 40mmm watch it looks out of proportion and wrong no matter how you look at it. Granted some of the new versions do look better, but the ones in the images you posted sorry but I can tell.

What does it matter anyway if your happy with the watch and you cant tell the difference thats all that matters wear it and enjoy it and ill stick to wearing and enjoying my gen black face 116520.
 

lcsrep11

Active Member
19/8/17
203
93
28
Toaday I have received 2 noob 116520 in black. Both are V2 versions. Ordered 3 weeks ago and received QC 2 days later.

SEL on both watches is good, no gaps. So they must have improved the quality on it. The printing on the dial is much better then V1, fonds are still off. Now the subdials are not even close to the gen. Color is not right and the size is too big. When I compare it with my 116520 in white, the subdials are much better on the white one. Size and color are 100 %gen. So if you do not want to franken it, go with the 116520 in white. Lume on all Noob watches is same as gen on holds over night. To me, the noob ceramic bezel is still the best.The ss bezel could be improoved but for the beginning it is ok. There are good quality ss aftermarket bezel available for $75. Check the latest picture with the quality of the ceramic bezel.

One point I have to made. When I got the 116500 black ceramic, the bezel was misaligned. After we changed the rep dial to a gen dial, the missalignment was gone. Sounds to me, that noob receives the case already assembled.

up to the pics

74bc95b20c0c76a400055c3fa1b8c892.jpg


2207cb29b85a0ac003469ce2486f8f8a.jpg


f95c1434aa1258590b58f9c684fe796f.jpg


2d23c01a60541bad49075e07cb3ac09b.jpg

My franken ceramic with gen dial compared to rep dial.
This dial is a CL lume dial for 116520 black

b0488d37b58393e6a2063d97e7f441b4.jpg


1fb678689f59a03d59faff0ef4f483b7.jpg


993f4d0104f04279be1ed985a9dd7b69.jpg

noob v2 black dial compared to noob v2 white dial

cc4a05e89ba222159d2352c33c85b804.jpg


92a74db95ca7363083702c137f11a439.jpg


d34f520ea235955cc43f13fcfd9c0a73.jpg

Franken ceramic compared with noob v2
148c6f0cf620146974d082230b7ee247.jpg



Sent from my iPad with Tapatalk

Totally agree with you. White face from what i've seen is for me the only one worth buying if your not going to franken it. The sub dials are huge compared to gen especially on black versions for some reason. Even to the eye anyone who knows a daytona will tell its off. It obviously looks worse magnified but to me the fatter sub dials just look so out of place and change the whole look of the watch.

Nice to see improvements happening so fast though certainly interesting times in the replica daytona world.
 

GregH

Known Member
25/6/18
124
15
0
The only big problem in the noob Daytona white dial is the dial right? How much it will cost to franken a gen dial?


Inviato dal mio iPhone utilizzando Tapatalk
 

guru

Advisor
Advisor
30/9/06
11,642
1,229
113
The only big problem in the noob Daytona white dial is the dial right? How much it will cost to franken a gen dial?


Inviato dal mio iPhone utilizzando Tapatalk

starting from 600 euros, depending on lume color


Sent from my iPad with Tapatalk
 

phdsjain

I'm Pretty Popular
6/3/14
2,007
893
113
The only big problem in the noob Daytona white dial is the dial right? How much it will cost to franken a gen dial?


Inviato dal mio iPhone utilizzando Tapatalk

Bezel too on the 116520. Font is off.
 

ssouthall6

Put Some Respect On My Name
10/10/13
3,539
1,562
113
If you were criticial about the clasp on the Noob 4130 bracelet, you cannot be now: Noob just updated it with a better one. One less thing to complain about. Just saw photos of it.
I know of course there are defects and tells and people should keep on bringing them up in the hopes of Noob taking notice and correcting them: the issues with the Noob dial are not just in the print quality, but also the 2-D shape of the indices and crown, the sizing of the sub-dial rings, and the lume quality. If they improve all of that, and their ceramic and SS timing ring (also not perfect, I know), then there is not much left for Noob to do except bump the whole mid-case up to 904L to have a thoroughly NWBIG rep. If the gen world takes notice of that development, then you will have about 10,000 impagtient, frustrated gen collectors ordering Noob Daytonas and taking their names off of the 8 year Rolex AD waiting list for the cer Daytona, dropping from that list like flies from a fly zapper. That development would amuse me if our TDs would not then have much longer waiting lists of their own. I think guru was hinting at this possible development in his previous posts: rep world meet gen world in collective Daytona fever.

Exactly. I'm not highlighting the faults just to annoy people that have bought it, nor am I an ARF fanboy (I made it pretty clear I refuse to buy a watch with stuck on subdial hands) but the hope is somehow this will be fed back in to noob and they will improve it, or it will alert potential buyers and help them build a closer to perfect watch.

The movement is amazing but the price of gen parts is much higher on this than a sub or datejust for example, which makes it prohibitive for as many to go the Franken route as the watch deserves.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
  • Like
Reactions: KJ2020

guru

Advisor
Advisor
30/9/06
11,642
1,229
113
The movement is amazing but the price of gen parts is much higher on this than a sub or datejust for example, which makes it prohibitive for as many to go the Franken route as the watch deserves.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Not when you are used to AP franken. ????



Sent from my iPad with Tapatalk
 

rolexwatchfan

Put Some Respect On My Name
17/8/13
4,224
799
0
Not when you are used to AP franken. ????



Sent from my iPad with Tapatalk

I have to side with guru on this one. Lets get serious for a moment here. We're talking about $15k plus gen watch price range.You're buying perfect platform from Noob to be able to Franken your watch however you want for about $650.00. Either you spend $900 or $7k on gen parts is up to you.
 

KJ2020

Time Traveler
Supporter
12/3/18
32,737
58,727
113
Has anyone actually put an ARF dial and ARF ceramic bezel on a new Noob 4130? Interested in knowing if there were any complications besides cutting the dial feet and using dial dots or similar.
 

nomana

Renowned Member
13/2/18
549
202
43
Some of the ARF Daytona lovers should come to Bangkok where I live . We have girls here with all kind of stuff that doesn’t function or shouldn’t be there Also missing functional stuff that should be there.

Lol