• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

[CONSENSUAL LIST] Super Reps NWBIGs

MarksandSpencer

MarksandSpencer

Active Member
24/4/17
348
78
28
Been using this guide for a while, props to Omagad for maintaining it also. just out curiosity, I'm surprised the Tank Solo (by a few makers) does not make any list here?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Omagad
M

Mr.Paneristi

You're Saying I Can Sell?
12/3/18
99
51
18
Livaren said:
Been using this guide for a while, props to Omagad for maintaining it also. just out curiosity, I'm surprised the Tank Solo (by a few makers) does not make any list here?
Click to expand...

The blue cabochon protrudes too far out on almost every solo I've seen.
 
C

chocolito

I'm Pretty Popular
12/9/17
1,661
860
113
Mr.Paneristi said:
The blue cabochon protrudes too far out on almost every solo I've seen.
Click to expand...

I have a ZF Tank Solo XL ( purchased 12 months ago ?) it has the correct shaped round cabachon . I would say it was a Super rep ( spent a lot of time comparing to gen) , although the straps are beyond shite !! I have put a beautiful gloss black lizard strap on mine . However I have noticed the cabachon on newer ZF , AF batches are wrong shape ( from posters pictures in Cartier section ) too long and are more in keeping with cabachon on the Tank Louis models .
 
S

Socialallure90

Known Member
31/5/18
132
17
18
chocolito said:
I have a ZF Tank Solo XL ( purchased 12 months ago ?) it has the correct shaped round cabachon . I would say it was a Super rep ( spent a lot of time comparing to gen) , although the straps are beyond shite !! I have put a beautiful gloss black lizard strap on mine . However I have noticed the cabachon on newer ZF , AF batches are wrong shape ( from posters pictures in Cartier section ) too long and are more in keeping with cabachon on the Tank Louis models .
Click to expand...

Which factory is yours ?
 
M

Mr.Paneristi

You're Saying I Can Sell?
12/3/18
99
51
18
chocolito said:
I have a ZF Tank Solo XL ( purchased 12 months ago ?) it has the correct shaped round cabachon . I would say it was a Super rep ( spent a lot of time comparing to gen) , although the straps are beyond shite !! I have put a beautiful gloss black lizard strap on mine . However I have noticed the cabachon on newer ZF , AF batches are wrong shape ( from posters pictures in Cartier section ) too long and are more in keeping with cabachon on the Tank Louis models .
Click to expand...

Interesting to hear ZF got it right on their previous version, and then botched it on their latest updated version. Currently, their small (women's) is sold out. Hopeful they will have a revision with the correct cabachon round shape in the near future, finding a place on the super rep/NWBIG list
 
C

chocolito

I'm Pretty Popular
12/9/17
1,661
860
113
Mr.Paneristi said:
Interesting to hear ZF got it right on their previous version, and then botched it on their latest updated version. Currently, their small (women's) is sold out. Hopeful they will have a revision with the correct cabachon round shape in the near future, finding a place on the super rep/NWBIG list
Click to expand...

Surprised the S is sold out because ONLY women can wear that watch it is tiny . I have a lot of watches on the consensual list and IMO the ZF tank solo is up there with the best of them for looking like the real thing . I purchased the XL date version and I have absolutely no worries about it being called out as a rep now I have changed the strap . However the cabachon on mine is correct . I have seen pictures of both the AF and ZF models on forums which have the LOUIS CARTIER wrongly shaped cabachon .

I DON'T have a previous version of the XL I have the current version . The watch hasn't been updated since I purchased it . However mine has the correct round cabachon ! The ones coming out of the factories recently do not .
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr.Paneristi
VIV54

VIV54

Renowned Member
13/12/17
688
392
63
Time to complete and update this list.

Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean 45.5 / 42mm (CrPO) VSF (8500 Super Clone)

It's been half year since this came out and we couldn't find a consensus.

The flaws are:

-slight difference in colour for the orange number model.
- 28000bpm rate instead of 25200 (never heard of someone calling a rep out just because the second hand runs too smooth)
- slight difference in insert being shinier than gen
- escapement barely visible through the caseback and no co-axial. (I doubt you can be called out without a loupe, but anyway..)

To me the silver number is definetely a Super rep.
the orange, too, but someone would say that the numbers are a different shade of orange (which depends on light).

Omagad
now you have all the details to decide if it's a super rep or not according to the super rep standards. Kind regards.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mr.Paneristi
Omagad

Omagad

I'm Pretty Popular
10/11/16
1,569
840
113
Super Reps Temple
VIV54 said:
Time to complete and update this list.

Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean 45.5 / 42mm (CrPO) VSF (8500 Super Clone)

It's been half year since this came out and we couldn't find a consensus.

The flaws are:

-slight difference in colour for the orange number model.
- 28000bpm rate instead of 25200 (never heard of someone calling a rep out just because the second hand runs too smooth)
- slight difference in insert being shinier than gen
- escapement barely visible through the caseback and no co-axial. (I doubt you can be called out without a loupe, but anyway..)

To me the silver number is definetely a Super rep.
the orange, too, but someone would say that the numbers are a different shade of orange (which depends on light).

Omagad
now you have all the details to decide if it's a super rep or not according to the super rep standards. Kind regards.
Click to expand...

Any full pics review?
 
beau7816

beau7816

Banned member, the goat does not approve
Banned
20/9/16
6,933
1,684
113
UK Devon
VIV54 I know there are certain watches that also should be on the list but I don't have edit privilege. My own Omega Aqua Terra came out recently and should also be on the list.
 
VIV54

VIV54

Renowned Member
13/12/17
688
392
63
Omagad said:
Any full pics review?
Click to expand...

IMG_6809.png

Genuine

IMG_6810.png

Replica

IMG_6812.png

Genuine

IMG_6811.png

Replica

IMG_6815.png

Genuine

IMG_6816.png

Replica

IMG_6818.png

Genuine

IMG_6817.png

Replica


Here you can see same weight as gen:
8bf74bdf6b234fa0ae812342cbe05751.jpg



Gen vs Rep:


And here you can see that the end links not folding properly which for some people was a obvious tell it's also in gens, so no flaw at all.

059da37b770ec46307cc0a318563d290.png


Let's don't forget that the movement is a clone movement and has the same features of the gen (power reserve, indipendent hour hand..)

Now you have all the material, IMHO silver numbers one is definitely a Super rep, it's up to you decide if orange numbers, too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ecender
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom