[CONSENSUAL LIST] Super Reps NWBIGs

[Vintage Lover]

All super reps are NWBIG, and First Class too.

First class = NWBIG. But all NWBIGs are not Super Reps.

Regarding the fact that the issue was accepted for a long time, it's because it was considered as minor flaw. Now, most Tudor fans (and gen owners) have heard about that issue and it will be the first thing they will look for.

Therefore, the issue is not acceptable anymore. That's why it has been removed. If you still think it belongs in First Class (NWBIG) list, I can add it to "under discussion" and I'll create a poll in the Tudor section.

I think it deserves a poll in the Tudor section and still believe it should be on the NWBIGs (FIRST CLASS) but refused as Super Rep list

I personally think the "rose issue" is a MINOR flaw and will be looking forward to see the results of the poll.

Thanks!

 

[904L]

This is such a helpful thread. Nice work!!

 

[Omagad]

UPDATE :

New category created to track watches that didn't get the NWBIG status. (Very nice rep but refused as NWBIG, no consensus reached)
Tudor BB Red Rose Edition ZF - V4/V5 added to that category because no consensus have been reached. See here.

 

[Muni]

Updated.

? Add 'sheild' to Tudor Blackbay Red 2016 ZF???

 

[Omagad]

? Add 'sheild' to Tudor Blackbay Red 2016 ZF???

done.

 

[d4m.test]

I'm new around these parts, and gradually increasing my knowledge. Thank for this informative thread.

 

[freediver]

great guide !
the only thing missing imo is availability ,because unfortunately many are not produced anymore

 

[mfrey89]

Brand new here and just made my first purchase base off recommendations here. Went with:
IWC 3878 Spitfire V6F
Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean 600m 42 (CrPO) Noob
Rolex Explorer II 42mm 216570 Noob (Correct Hand Stack)

Sorry for the shitpost, just pumped to get and review.

 

[Muni]

Brand new here and just made my first purchase base off recommendations here. Went with:
IWC 3878 Spitfire V6F
Omega Seamaster Planet Ocean 600m 42 (CrPO) Noob
Rolex Explorer II 42mm 216570 Noob (Correct Hand Stack)

Sorry for the shitpost, just pumped to get and review.

You been a member since 2013 and just made your first purchase now?

 

[mfrey89]

You been a member since 2013 and just made your first purchase now?

Yeah, I lurked for awhile and needed the cash for my other expensive hobbies haha

 

[Muni]

Yeah, I lurked for awhile and needed the cash for my other expensive hobbies haha

'Lurked for awhile' is an understatement.
Ha let me guess, women, cars,booze and maybe drugs...lol jokes

 

[Thatwatchguy]

great guide !
the only thing missing imo is availability ,because unfortunately many are not produced anymore

Agree this would be very helpful @Omagad this would inhance the list to the next level ie TD available or OLD STOCK m2m (if you're lucky)

Again brilliant list already

 

[Muni]

Agree this would be very helpful @Omagad this would inhance the list to the next level ie TD available or OLD STOCK m2m (if you're lucky)

Again brilliant list already

And picture of the best dial colour to go for. As some may be more super rep in some dials colours than other (e.g. HBB).
But amazing work nevertheless.

 

[Omagad]

And picture of the best dial colour to go for. As some may be more super rep in some dials colours than other (e.g. HBB).
But amazing work nevertheless.

Agree this would be very helpful @Omagad this would inhance the list to the next level ie TD available or OLD STOCK m2m (if you're lucky)

Again brilliant list already

Thanks guys.

Regarding your recommendations, yeah, but no

The purpose of this list isn't to avoid anyone to do their own research but to help them understand what to look for. As stated :

If you decide to buy one of these watches because
it is in this list, please always take the time to
understand WHY it's in the list, check reviews,
make sure you understand what you're buying.

 

[Omagad]

Update : Tudor Black Pelagos ZF V3 removed from Super Rep list because of the bezel font (specially the "40" where the 0 is too wide and the 4 is too skinny).

Added this :

Note that if there are several super reps of the
same model and unless both are of exact same
quality, only the best one will be listed here.

 

[d4m.test]

Why isn't Calibre De Carter (rubber strap) considered as a super rep ?

 

[Repworld]

Why isn't Calibre De Carter (rubber strap) considered as a super rep ?

It’s super Rep waiting New Batch it’s out of stock now..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[mysterio]

It’s super Rep waiting New Batch it’s out of stock now..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

It's not listed in the first post, so how did you come to that conclusion?

 

[Repworld]

It’s super Rep 100% waiting for subdial unseen fix in new Batch


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Omagad]

It's not listed in the first post, so how did you come to that conclusion?

It’s super Rep waiting New Batch it’s out of stock now..


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Well, this list is all about having a consensus. It will enter the list as soon as almost everyone agrees.