• Tired of adverts on RWI? - Subscribe by clicking HERE and PMing Trailboss for instructions and they will magically go away!

New JF Royal Oak Tourbillon Review/Comparison with old RO Tourby Rep

capnjazz

Known Member
10/4/15
166
44
28
JF Royal Oak Extra-Thin Tourbillon


It's finally here, the long awaited JF RO Tourby Rep... Does it live up to the hype??

wPTRa.jpg

wPhry.jpg


It certainly appears to be a major improvement over the old RO Tourbillon replica. I'm not sure what factory made that one, but while still a great watch, there were many visible flaws. While this rep is still a far cry from being a 1:1 with the gen, it's still a fantastic watch!

First up, lets take a look at the front of the watch. The bezel 'screws' are much closer to the Gen size and are much better machined. The gold gear beneath the hand stack that pokes out into the Tourbillon opening is bigger as per the gen. The only thing that seems to be a slight step backwards here is the size of the balance wheel. It is noticeably smaller on the new JF Rep, leaving a pretty large gap in the balance wheel diameter to opening diameter ratio. On the Get the balance wheel and the gold gear overlap a bit. The "Swiss Made" printing on the dial is much better on the new JF Rep, as the old was far too large.

wPwIe.jpg


The dial pattern is slightly better.. the "squares" of the dial pattern are a bit smaller, but still not as small as the gen dial. There are 5 squares along the top hour marker on the Gen, but only 4 on both Reps due to the larger pattern size.

wwze6.jpg


The JF Rep is ever so slightly thinner than the old rep. But neither come close to the thickness of the Gen.

woKnL.jpg


The caseback movement decoration is substantially better, despite having an "Audemars Piguet" sticker, rather than being engraved with the brand name. The orientation of the gears and such on the JF Rep is correct as per Gen, whereas the old rep had the layout reversed. There is now a Power Reserve Dial, but they made a glaring mistake and left out the PR hand... This was likely because they used the movement renders from AP's website as a reference, and those renders don't include the actual dial hand. A bit bummed about that, but at least its a mistake on the back of the watch. The font of used for the "Royal Oak" engraving at the top as well as the serial number at the bottom is incorrect on both the Reps. But the JF Rep correctly DOESN'T have all the extra engravings around the caseback that were incorrectly present on the old Rep. While hard to tell in the photo, the rear bridge across the Tourbillon has a polished appearance as per Gen, whereas the old Rep incorrectly has a brushed finish.

wPGiK.jpg


The bracelet of the JF isn't as "floppy" as the old Rep. Not sure if that is closer to Gen or not.

Old Rep on left, JF Rep on right
wPAwr.jpg


Summery

I really like the improvements on this new model, especially considering the movement on my old RO Tourby Rep started having issues coincidentally the day I received my new JF Rep. (I'll be taking the old Rep apart and attempting to fix that or at least diagnose the issue and make another post documenting that) The watch is stunning!

Here's a bonus shot of the reps side by side, plus a shot of the JF next to my Gen Royal Oak 15300OR.
wP4n0.jpg

wwtgD.jpg
 
Last edited:

theREALgoat

Put Some Respect On My Name
Patron
Certified
14/8/14
5,033
2,772
113
It doesn't look like a significant difference as far as thickness, and I really question why JF went with a smaller balance wheel than the other RO tourbillon reps, the small balance wheel is something that really stands out to me. Other than that it looks pretty decent, maybe something worth picking up M2M. Thanks for sharing!
 

m1994

Renowned Member
Supporter
Certified
18/7/17
517
533
93
Great review and great pictures, Thanks for sharing!
 

QueTip

Super Duper Galactic NutSwinging BootyGrabbin Mod
Staff member
Global Moderator
Certified
3/6/14
14,309
5,243
113
Thanks for sharing.
 

reppin

Renowned Member
27/5/12
911
332
63
looks great on wrist, could we get a couple more wrist shots mate?
 

odonreps

You're Saying I Can Sell?
21/9/18
64
15
8
Actually, now liking the blue. How much darker do you think the dial is vs gen?